• Question: Do you believe that there will one day be a cure for cancer?

    Asked by AWSOME TORTOISE 42 to Barbara, Matt, Ravinder, Sophie, Tristan on 10 Mar 2015.
    • Photo: Sophie Robinson

      Sophie Robinson answered on 10 Mar 2015:


      We can’t ‘cure cancer’, but we can stay one step ahead of it.Cancer’s ability to evolve drug resistance makes it impossible to eradicate, but we may one day transform it from a killer into a long-term illness. Cancer is an extraordinarily diverse and complex group of diseases, not just one illness.

      The reality is that many researchers, myself included, don’t believe we will ever cure cancer. For a start, trying to develop a single “cure for cancer” would be like trying to develop a single cure for Aids, depression, the flu or a broken leg. We’re making progress in designing treatments for specific cancers, but they adapt quickly, with many of them evolving in such a way that they can resist being killed by drugs.

      This presents an enormous challenge. Some of the best treatments will only work for a limited time before resistance kicks in. But understanding resistance will help us to defeat it.
      Some cancers become resistant by switching on special survival proteins when they sense danger. One such protein is PI3K, which is activated when cancer cells are attacked by a drug. PI3K, once activated, goes on to activate other proteins that have other effects that help cells survive under stressful conditions. One will trigger cells to reproduce more, another will hack into the body’s healthy blood supply to hijack nutrients, and another will block the signals that tell a cell to commit suicide when it gets old.

      Drugs are being designed to block this kind of chain reaction. For example, last year a clinical trial showed that a drug called Afinitor could potentially thwart resistance caused by the PI3K pathway in some cancers, by blocking the action of one of the chemicals in this pathway.

      Another way cancers avoid being killed by drugs is by using “pump proteins” that eject the drug from the cell. One such protein is called P-gp, and it evolved as a way to protect us against infection. Its normal function is to push pathogens such as bacteria out of our cells before they have a chance to make us ill.

      Scientists have been trying to block the action of the P-gp pump for decades, but it has turned out to be difficult to interfere with it without harming the patient. However, every study that hasn’t quite worked has brought us one step closer to a solution. Last month, an article was published in the journal BMC Cancer reporting that a new drug may be able to reverse chemotherapy resistance caused by P-gp. More tests will be needed before we know if this drug can be given to patients, but the research is encouraging.

      I do believe there will come a time when we know these resistance mechanisms so well that there will always be a new therapy, and cancer will become a long-term illness, treated with one drug until that drug stops working, at which point the patient will be switched to a different drug.
      We have made dazzling progress in the past few decades with the invention of targeted drugs that don’t have the side-effects of chemotherapy, and this improved quality of life for patients will only get better with time.

    • Photo: Matthew Moore

      Matthew Moore answered on 10 Mar 2015:


      It would be a long time from now if there was! There are about 100 different types of cancer which behave differently often depending where they are in the body. Cancer broadly speaking is abnormal cell growth.

      Cells are really complicated and the way cancer cells avoid being destroyed by the immune system varies greatly!

      One of the most important factors in treating cancers is diagnosing it early enough!

      There are also examples of organisms that don’t get cancer, understanding this would be helpful towards tackling the majority of cancers.

    • Photo: Barbara Shih

      Barbara Shih answered on 10 Mar 2015:


      It’s an interesting question. I sure hope there will be a cure for cancer someday. There are certainly people who really believe we’re close to curing cancer- Peter Thiel apparently takes growth hormones, whichmight increase his risk of cancer but reduces risk of several other disorders, because he is hopeful cancer will be cured in the next decade. (http://uk.businessinsider.com/peter-thiel-is-taking-human-growth-hormones-hgh-2014-12)

      I believe we will have good treatments/early diagnosis for most types of cancers in the next 20 years or so, but a straight out “cure” for all cancer is probably not likely, especially not for late stage cancers.

Comments